Papa Johns Pizza

Experience friendly service and delicious seafood, thickshakes, and more at Papa Johns Pizza Shopping Place. A local favorite for all!
  • 3.5 312 rating
  • 3801 University Blvd W Ste 1, Jacksonville, FL 32217, United States
  • +1 904-443-7272

Why Locals Love Papa Johns Pizza

Located conveniently at 3801 University Blvd W in Jacksonville, FL, Papa John's Pizza offers a delightful experience for pizza lovers craving both classic and innovative flavors. This well-established pizza restaurant specializes in hand-tossed, freshly baked pies crafted exactly to your preferences, promising a personalized dining experience every time.

The menu stands out with its signature Create Your Own Pizza option, allowing you to build a custom masterpiece starting at $14.19. Whether you prefer classic pepperoni, fresh veggies, or adventurous toppings, every pizza is made from scratch with quality ingredients and baked to perfection. For those looking to elevate their pizza game, the Epic Stuffed Crust Pizza at $21.59 offers a richly satisfying indulgence with a pillowy, cheese-stuffed crust that adds a luxurious twist to your favorite toppings. The Garlic Epic Stuffed Crust version adds an extra layer of savory, aromatic flavor that's bound to delight your taste buds.

No pizza experience is complete without delicious sides, and Papa John's excels here as well. Their Wings selection features options like oven-baked Garlic Parmesan Boneless Wings and spicy Buffalo Wings, both priced at $11.49 and served with your choice of dipping sauce. These wings strike the perfect balance between tender, juicy chicken and flavorful coatings that enhance without overpowering.

Beyond pizza and wings, the Papadias present a creative take on flatbread sandwiches. The BBQ Chicken & Bacon Papadia features grilled chicken, smoky bacon, onions, cheese, and tangy BBQ sauce, providing a comforting yet exciting option for those craving something different. Meanwhile, the Philly Cheesesteak Papadia brings the beloved Philly flavor right to your plate with savory steak, green peppers, and gooey cheese, perfect for a satisfying meal on the go.

The atmosphere at this Papa John’s location reflects its community-focused spirit. Customers consistently commend the friendly and efficient service, with staff who genuinely care about delivering quality food quickly—even during peak hours. One loyal customer, Joe Mahaney, praises the team for their respectful and supportive environment, highlighting how this positively impacts the overall dining experience. Amanda, a staff member mentioned in reviews, goes above and beyond to ensure customer satisfaction by swiftly resolving any issues, demonstrating the restaurant’s commitment to a “customer first” approach.

Fans like Ashli Heeter appreciate the speedy deliveries and generous portions, noting the satisfaction of receiving their fresh, hot pizzas without long waits. Likewise, Shane Jeffers admires the consistency of the food and service, confident that every order will meet high standards. Small but thoughtful touches such as extra sauce requests being fulfilled without hesitation add to the warm, welcoming feeling that permeates this location.

Whether you’re craving a late-night pizza fix, gathering with friends or family, or just in search of a comforting meal made with care, Papa John's Pizza on University Blvd in Jacksonville stands out as a dependable choice. Its blend of customizable options, flavorful specialties, attentive staff, and inviting atmosphere invites you to enjoy a truly satisfying pizza experience that keeps customers coming back time and again.

What Makes This Place Friendly

  • No-contact delivery
  • Delivery
  • Takeaway
  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Wheelchair-accessible car park
  • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
  • Comfort food
  • Late-night food
  • Quick bite
  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Catering
  • Dessert
  • Table service
  • Casual
  • University students
  • Accepts reservations
  • Credit cards
  • Debit cards
  • NFC mobile payments
  • Credit cards
  • Free of charge street parking
  • Free parking lot

When & Where to Visit

  • 10:00 AM - 12:00 AM
  • 10:00 AM - 12:00 AM
  • 10:00 AM - 12:00 AM
  • 10:00 AM - 12:00 AM
  • 10:00 AM - 01:00 AM
  • 10:00 AM - 01:00 AM
  • 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM

Real Reviews from the Community

Joe Mahaney
  • Mar 19, 2026
5

My family and I order from this Papa John's religiously and Jessica took care of our order tonight and a guy she was training the food was amazing. I will say it's nice to hear a gm not talk to their employees like they are lower than them. Best Papa John's in all of Jacksonville....it wouldn't let me post a review on the papa johns website so if this can be relayed to upper management that would be awesome !!

Ashli Heeter
  • Mar 5, 2026
4

2020 update. This Papa John's has been doing better, I just got my order and it was super fast (25min to the door) papatrack showed it as still "making". The breadsticks were plentiful (although little skinny , oh well) and the pizzas looked delish (still need help on cutting, one was small other was huge). 2018 _ I love Papa John's but since I moved to this new area it has been lacking. First time we ordered from this location the cheese sticks were all flat, and now tonight we ordered and the pizza was flat ! Even though we ordered "Original " crust ! I'm just disappointed because I love Papa John's, but hate thin crust...

Shane Jeffers
  • Feb 20, 2026
5

Just can't say enough about Papa John's. Superior service and quality food.. even during times you think they will be busy (they usually are) I have NEVER gotten bad food and the occasional time I may have a complaint.. the team rectifies it upon immediate request.. truly a shopper friendly "Customer first" approach by this store.. If someone has something bad to say.. well they just were having a bad day and wouldn't let the situation be resolved because I know personally that this crew will go above AND BEYOND to make an issue right.

Paul Reichman
  • Feb 16, 2026
5

So I ordered a pizza on Saturday night and didn't have a very good experience I won't go into details however I called back after trying to get through a couple times I finally got through on Tuesday. The person I spoke with named Amanda went out of her way to send me another Pizza as well as a couple drinks all at no charge. Awesome deal thank you Papa John's you're the best

Jenny Allen
  • Jan 18, 2026
5

I asked for extra sauce and holy cow! They gave me extra sauce! Thank you!

Nikki B
  • Dec 20, 2025
5

So far, this is my new favorite location. The service and food has been on point every time. Today I ordered from here and since the peppers were small, they put 2 of them in the pizza box. Its the little things. Thanks for doing an awesome job! I will continue to bring my business.

Angelica Elsen
  • Dec 11, 2025
5

Great service! We had issues using our papa dough points online and called the store he said he will cancel our order so we can try again. We did shortly before we got to the store and our pizza was made faster than expected and came out so fresh and delicious.

Dawne Gladden
  • Dec 3, 2025
5

Was at a ball tournament at a nearby park and could not leave. The employees of this store were so kind to make an exception and deliver to me. The concession sold out early and we were still playing well into the night. Thank you so much

Share Your Experience
Select your rating

More Friendly Places You May Like

Le Parisien
  • 4.71706 rating
  • Open now!
Little Caesars Pizza
  • 3.7699 rating
  • Open now!
Taco Bell
  • 3.7296 rating
  • Open now!
Chipotle Mexican Grill
  • 3.71248 rating
  • Open now!
Pizza Hut
  • 4.11221 rating
  • Open now!